Search Mailing List Archives
[liberationtech] Fwd: Evgeny Morozov ('The Net Delusion') curbs Web enthusiasm - latimes.com
winograd at cs.stanford.edu
Sat Jun 23 10:02:03 PDT 2012
Evgeny Morozov ('The Net Delusion') curbs Web enthusiasm - latimes.com
Evgeny Morozov, in warning of 'iPod liberalism' at a TED conference and
taking on tech giants in the New Republic and elsewhere, is a leading
[image: Evgeny Morozov]
Evgeny Morozov is an outspoken critic of “iPod liberalism” who has written
about the downsides of Google’s Street View, Steve Jobs’ Apple work and
more. (Carolyn Cole, Los Angeles Times / June 21, 2012)
By James Rainey, Los Angeles Times
June 21, 2012
When Iranians rose up and marched against their rulers, people around the
world felt they were there. Facebook bristled with video from the streets
of Tehran. Revolutionary-green avatars sprouted across the Web.
Commentators heralded a coming "Twitter Revolution."
The euphoria was pervasive — until a radical skeptic punctured the
Evgeny Morozov, a virtually unknown writer and sometime technology
advocate, launched his counteroffensive three years ago at the annual TED
What Morozov told the crowd at Oxford University amounted to heresy in some
circles: Beware of "iPod liberalism … the assumption that every Iranian and
Chinese person that happens to love their iPod will also love liberal
Don't forget that the Internet can be used not just to empower freedom
fighters but to hunt them down through their online presence.
"The KGB used to torture in order to get this data. Now it's all available
online," Morozov deadpanned.
He described how autocrats hired their own bloggers to drown out democrats.
He shared studies about what young people really did online. They consumed
"not reports from Human Rights Watch. It's going to be pornography,'Sex and
the City' or maybe watching funny videos of cats."
Morozov left the stage with a thin smile to polite applause. But in the
world of Internet intellectuals and writers, the conversation began to
"Evgeny was one of the few people making sense at that moment," said Siva
Vaidhyanathan, a University of Virginia professor of media studies. "There
was this naive optimism about how Twitter was going to liberate Iran, and
he presented this well-thought-out argument about what wishful thinking
that was. It was so refreshing."
The pasty young man in the rumpled dress shirt was only getting started.
With his 2011 book "The Net Delusion: The Dark Side of Internet Freedom,"
he cemented his reputation as a fierce critical voice — exploding the
notion that technology equals liberation. Since then, his slashing
critiques have taken on pillars of the Web — Apple, Facebook and Google —
as well as Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, among others.
At 28 and wickedly sarcastic ("There are idiots. Look around," says his
Twitter [@evgenymorozov <https://twitter.com/evgenymorozov>] billboard),
Morozov has emerged from the obscurity of his native Belarus as a leading
voice of dissent against "cyber utopians" — the marketers, entrepreneurs
and academics he sees as throwing over the lessons of history in a rush to
promote the Internet as the solution to most of society's* *challenges.
He's the *enfant terrible* of a group that includes the New Yorker's Malcolm
Gladwell, Berkeley-based techno-humanist Jaron Lanier and former
CNNcorrespondent Rebecca MacKinnon, author of "Consent of the
Most recently based at Stanford University, as a fellow in the Liberation
Technology Program, he is putting aside his Kindle, iPhone and iPad to
finish "Silicon Democracy: How the Geeks Are Stealing Your Freedoms," due
in bookstores next spring. He says it will be "a full-frontal attack" on
Web triumphalists and their reflexive "quest for efficiency, transparency,
connectedness, quantification and perfection."
While others gush about unparalleled change, he finds historic antecedents
for the Internet revolution. The current giddiness over cyber-life, he
thinks, echoes the 17th century's fascination with the clock.
Critics depict him as more heckler than thinker and suggest he picks easy
targets and overstates their naivete about the Web. Clay Shirky, a New York
University professor who has written two bestselling books about the
Internet's potential, agrees with Morozov on occasion but finds him a
too-ready champion of a pessimistic old guard.
"Anyone who believes what his opponents believe is not to be trusted,"
Shirky said. "He does this with a distressingly broad brush."
On a recent jaunt around New York, Morozov headlined three events — a
panel, a debate and an interview at a club on the Upper East Side. If he
was impressed by the attention, it did not show.
"I've got a couple of books to finish tonight," he said, before rushing off
from the late-night panel.
Morozov grew up in the industrial town of Soligorsk, in a country squeezed
between Poland and Russia. Both his parents worked at the local potassium
mine, but he proved a precocious student and found his way to the American
University in Bulgaria.
He earned a bachelor's degree in business and economics and was on a path
to an investment banking career until a professor got him thinking about
geopolitics. He landed at Transitions Online in Prague, which promotes
democracy in the former Soviet states. He hopped from Kyrgyzstan to
Slovakia, evangelizing about the power of organizing online.
As recently as 2009, he was theorizing that the spread of the Kindle "could
easily make censorship obsolete."
But he started to have misgivings, he said in a recent interview, when
evidence accumulated that autocrats were abusing the Internet.
"I saw governments becoming extremely sophisticated in censorship,
surveillance and propaganda online," he recalled.
In 2010, he became suspicious of a much-hyped software program called
Haystack — promoted as a tool to help Iranian freedom fighters circumvent
censorship — and took the program to Jacob Appelbaum. The cybersecurity
whiz needed just six hours to detect vulnerabilities in the code.
Morozov, writing in Slate and Foreign Policy, then excoriated Hillary
Clinton and media outlets for eagerly embracing a software that could have
exposed the activists to government reprisals.
His cautionary words in the New Republic about the intrusiveness of Google
Street View, the search giant's project to create a photographic tableau of
streetscapes worldwide, were also ahead of the curve. Recent revelations
showed that Google's mobile picture cars sucked passwords and other data
from unprotected Wi-Fi networks.
But he can overreach. On a panel show hosted by the television network Al
Jazeera last year, Morozov said that although Facebook helped organize
Syrian dissidents, it failed to spur "real-world protests." Within weeks,
the country exploded in marches and demonstrations, triggering a violent
"He has overestimated the strength of autocrats and underestimated the
strength of insurgents," Shirky said, pointing to the toppling of dictators
in last year's Arab Spring rebellions.
Morozov responds that his book acknowledged the mobilizing power of Twitter
and Facebook. It cautioned only against forgetting about the cultural,
social and political factors required for those digital seeds to land in
fertile soil. As recent events in Egypt show, the resilience of insurgent
movements will depend less on a blizzard of tweets, he notes, than on the
realpolitik of voting and coalition building.
Morozov's writing has impressed editors worldwide. Spain's El Pais
andItaly'sCorriere della Sera are among the newspapers that carry his
monthly column. His writing about the Iranian rebellion also caught the eye
of Leon Wieseltier, literary editor of the New Republic, who saw him as
"singularly immune to the dizziness" surrounding the Internet and capable
of reanimating debate about the impact of technology.
The magazine, which publishes his exhaustive book reviews, has become
Morozov's critical redoubt. He spanked Google for being cavalier about the
pitfalls inherent in imperfect algorithms. He cited the case of an Italian
man to whose name the search engine's "auto complete" function added two
inaccurate descriptors — "conman" and "fraud."
Morozov's savage review of Jeff Jarvis' "Public Parts: How Sharing in the
Digital Age Improves the Way We Work and Live" accused Jarvis of falling
"under the spell of geek religion" — viewing the Internet as "the glue that
holds our globalized world together and the divine numen that fills it with
The self-made scholar from Europe worries about America's "quasi-religious
feelings about technology." Perhaps his hardest shot at this orthodoxy came
in March, with a New Republic cover story titled "The iGod: A
Semi-Heretical Look at the Religion of Apple."
Nominally a review of a Steve Jobs biography, it quickly dismissed Walter
Isaacson's bestseller as "pedestrian." Morozov suggested an alternative
view of Jobs, not as the "visionary" of recent obituaries but as a
"marketing genius who turned an ordinary company into a mythical cult,
while he himself was busy settling old scores and serving the demands of
his titanic ego."
Jobs' frothy sermonizing, Morozov wrote, hid a bottom-line imperative —
herd as many customers as possible away from the freewheeling Web and into
an Apple-application garden, creating "nothing more than an efficient
His next book will include an attack on the "open data" movement. In one
cautionary example, the Indian state of Karnataka put millions of property
records online in the name of convenience and transparency.
"The wealthy and the powerful used this new data to evict the poor, find
the right people to bribe and so forth," Morozov said. "The moral of the
story here is that transparency and efficiency should not be pursued for
their own sake. They should serve as enabling factors to other goods and
He believes that self-interested capitalists and "charlatans who claim to
be futurists and visionaries" have dominated talk about the Internet. When
he enrolls at Harvard in the fall to pursue a PhD in the history of
science, it will be with an eye toward shifting the debate to a "richer
approach," one that is more historically and culturally literate.
When anyone steps out of line, he will pound away, one withering essay at a
*james.rainey at latimes.com*
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the liberationtech