Search Mailing List Archives

Limit search to: Subject & Body Subject Author
Sort by: Reverse Sort
Limit to: All This Week Last Week This Month Last Month
Select Date Range     through    

[liberationtech] Kill the Messenger: What Russia taught Syria

Brian Conley brianc at
Sat Mar 3 20:51:40 PST 2012

I have to respecfully disagree. If our only concern is to properly scare
people about the implications of targeting based on RF transmissions, then
yes, the article does a good job of that.

My concern is to ensure that journalists, activists, and their enablers
have access to the best information and the most likely/accurate review of
events about which we may never have "facts."

I guess I should specify the elements of the article that I consider to be
sensational, speculative, and/or downright misleading/scare-mongering.

First of all, Mr. Pelton is well known for being a glory-hound, his book
"The World's Most Dangerous Places" should be enough to make that clear.

So firstly, he starts with his own "glory days" covering Chechnya, and the
first issue I would raise is this quote:

"As we walked briskly back to the safe house, it was exactly 10 minutes
before the cascade of double *wa-whumps* announced the Grad rocket
batteries pounding the vacant neighborhood we had just left."

Mr. Pelton has mentioned previously in a forum of journalists, human rights
reporters, and their colleagues(fixers, translators etc), known as the
Vulture Club, that the Russians have equipment that can lock onto an RF
signal and fire Grad rockets at the location within a matter of minutes,
taking merely 10 minutes from starting a phone call to hitting the
location. I asked him repeatedly if he would clarify which targeting
system, specifically, Unfortunately none of the details he provided
suggested such a capacity, therefore while it's certainly possible this
capacity exists, to just state it as fact, to my mind, qualifies as
scaremongering, and does not serve to improve our general understanding of
the risks of satellite communications.

There follows three paragraphs serving only to establish that yes indeed
journalists have been directly targeted in Russia's war in Chechnya. This
is then used to suggest it is self-evident that:

" journalists were specifically targeted to prevent sympathetic or
embarrassing reports from escaping the killing zone."

This is just outright unsubstantiated. There was one account in the
Telegraph paper that sourced Lebanese intelligence stating that the Syrian
regime has claimed it would target journalists directly. If it is prime
facie fact, isn't it strange that there is only one source and no other
papers directly carried this allegation?

Next Mr. Pelton asserts that satellite phone uplinks:

"could well have cost Colvin her life." and "Multiple reports have
Syrian forces used phone signals to pinpoint her location"

Now then, if Mr. Pelton were simply another ignorant journalist printing
what he understood as potential threats, that would be one thing, however
he has been privy to extended discussions about the relative improbability
that satellite phones were targeted, vs the much more likely case that the
VSAT and/or BGAN on the roof of the "makeshift media centre" or, equally
likely, old-fashioned human intelligence targeting resulted in the deaths
of the individuals noted. Further these "multiple reports" are essentially
rehashings of the same initial report, of which Mr. Pelton should be well

It is very sad that Colvin and Ochlik were killed, and other journalists
grievously wounded. It's even more sad that so many Syrians lost their
lives evacuating the survivors. Given these facts and the importance of
honoring their loss, I would prefer to see less hyperbole and
sensationalism and more soul-searching and review of just how these events

As I stated last week on this list, Marie Colvin herself was quoted as
saying that she would not use her satellite phone because of her fear that
it could be intercepted/targeted. Instead she opted to depend on Skype
which, though variously secure, relies on a much higher bandwidth
connection which is vastly easier to target. Rather than continuing the
magical thinking that may well have led to Colvin's death, we should take a
hard look at what we know about the facts and review the lack of
approachable, available documentation about communications security,
particularly satellite-based communications.


On Sat, Mar 3, 2012 at 6:47 PM, Jillian C. York <jilliancyork at>wrote:

> Not really. The writer clearly notes that this is reported, not fact, and
> these lessons, if not pertinent to Colvin specifically, no doubt will be.
> As you note, it's still all speculation, but the author makes that pretty
> clear.
>  On Mar 3, 2012 5:49 PM, "Brian Conley" <brianc at> wrote:
>> There is all kinds of sensationalism and speculation in this article.
>> Further, I think I've already clearly explained that the speculation the
>> journalists were directly targeted is speculation and the most likely
>> transmissions related target is the satellite modem setup likely provided
>> by Avaaz to the opposition, not the phones.
>> Sent from my iPad
>> On Mar 3, 2012, at 17:16, Rafal Rohozinski <r.rohozinski at>
>> wrote:
>> Good article on TAC SIGINT capabilities for laypersons.
>> Rafal
>>  Kill the Messenger<> What
>> Russia taught Syria: When you destroy a city, make sure no one -- not even
>> the story -- gets out alive.
>> It was a star-filled night in Chechnya's besieged capital of Grozny. The
>> snow crunched under my feet as I walked with the Chechen rebel commander
>> away from the warmth of our safe house. When we entered a bombed-out
>> neighborhood 15 minutes away, I put the battery in my Iridium satellite
>> phone**and waited for the glowing screen to signal that I had locked on
>> to the satellites.
>> I made my call. It was short. Then the commander made a call; he quickly
>> hung up and handed me back the phone. "Enough," he said, motioning for me
>> to remove the battery.
>> As we walked briskly back to the safe house, it was exactly 10 minutes
>> before the cascade of double *wa-whumps* announced the Grad rocket
>> batteries pounding the vacant neighborhood we had just left.
>> It was December 1999, and the Russian assault on Grozny was unfolding in
>> all its gruesome detail. After the dissolution of so much of the former
>> Soviet empire, Chechnya was one country that the newly minted prime
>> minister, Vladimir Putin, refused to let go of. His boss, Boris Yeltsin,
>> and the Russian army had been defeated and then humiliated in the media by
>> Chechen forces in the first war. Five years later, Russia was back. And
>> Putin's new strategy was unbending: silence, encircle, pulverize, and
>> "cleanse." It was a combination of brutal tactics -- a Stalinist purge of
>> fighting-age males plus Orwellian propaganda that fed Russians a narrative
>> wherein Chechen freedom fighters were transformed into Islamist mercenaries
>> and terrorists. More than 200,000 civilians were to die in this war, the
>> echoes of which continue to this day.
>> This time, journalists were specifically targeted to prevent sympathetic
>> or embarrassing reports from escaping the killing zone. As such, you can't
>> find a lot of stories about the second Chechen war. One of the few and best
>> accounts was written by Marie Colvin, who described her terrifying escape
>> from Grozny for the *Sunday Times*. Last month, Colvin thought she could
>> roll the dice and enter the besieged Syrian city of Homs to defy yet
>> another brutal war of oppression. This time she lost.
>> It's impossible to know whether Syrian President Bashar al-Assad -- a
>> longtime ally of Russia -- studied the success of the last Chechen war
>> before launching his own assault on the restive city of Homs. However, his
>> Russian military advisors surely know the tactics well. The crackdown in
>> Homs carries a grim echo of Grozny, both in its use of signals intelligence
>> to track down and silence the regime's enemies and in its bloody
>> determination to obliterate any opposition, including Western journalists.
>> Assad's ability to lethally target journalists using satellite-phone
>> uplinks could well have cost Colvin her life. Multiple reports have
>> suggested<> that
>> Syrian forces used phone signals to pinpoint her location and then launched
>> a rocket barrage that resulted in her death on Feb. 22, along with that of
>> French photographer Remi Ochlik and multiple Syrian civilians.
>> The use of satellite and cellular transmissions to determine a subject's
>> location was relatively new a decade ago, when I was in Grozny. Tracking
>> phone transmissions to hunt down targets began in earnest with a covert
>> unit of U.S. intelligence officers from the National Security Agency (NSA),
>> CIA, Navy, Air Force, and special operations called "The Activity." This
>> snooping unit was also called the Army of Northern Virginia, Grey Fox, and
>> even Task Force Orange. We see much of this technology used to inform
>> modern drone and U.S. Joint Special Operations Command strikes. My decade
>> covering U.S. spec ops, intelligence gathering, and their contractors
>> highlighted the impressive ability of various countries to monitor, locate,
>> network, and act on what is called SIGINT, or signals intelligence.
>> The Russians have their own version of this capability, which fell under
>> the command of the Federal Agency of Government Communications and
>> Information <>, now part of the
>> Federal Protective Service. In the United States, it would be equivalent to
>> the NSA and FBI combined, and the agency provides sophisticated
>> eavesdropping support to Russia's military, intelligence, and
>> counterterrorism units -- and to Russia's allies, including Syria.
>> Russia has spent a long time perfecting these techniques. On April 21,
>> 1996, Chechnya's breakaway president, Dzhokhar Dudayev, was speaking on a
>> satellite phone* *with Russian envoy Konstantin Borovoi about setting
>> peace talks with Yeltsin. During the phone call, he was killed<> by
>> a signal-guided missile fired from a Russian jet fighter. The warplane had
>> received Dudayev's coordinates from a Russian ELINT (electronic
>> intelligence)* *plane that had picked up and locked on to the signal
>> emitted by the satellite phone. It was Russian deception and brutality at
>> its finest.
>> It should have been clear even back then that there was a benefit and a
>> distinct penalty to modern communications on the battlefield.
>> Flash forward to Syria today. The opposition Free Syrian Army is
>> officially run by a former air force colonel who commands a barely
>> organized group of army defectors supported by energetic youth. They rely
>> almost entirely on cell-phone service, satellite phones, the Internet, and
>> social media to organize and communicate. Early in February, according to a
>> Fox News report, Qatar provided3,000 satellite phones<>,
>> which the Syrian rebels have used to upload numerous impactful videos and
>> stories.
>> These past few weeks, under a barrage of mortar, tank, and artillery
>> shells, their plaintive calls for help from inside the besieged Baba Amr
>> neighborhood of Homs sparked international outrage. But without Western
>> journalists filing for newspapers and television outlets, these videos --
>> mostly shaky, low-resolution footage of corpses and artillery strikes --
>> wouldn't have had the impact they deserve.
>> In a welcome resurgence of non-embedded journalism, brave reporters like
>> Colvin and many others risked their lives to enter Homs and report from the
>> ground. What they showed us was moving, horrific, and embarrassing. Once
>> again, Western governments were caught doing nothing -- while women,
>> children, and innocents were murdered by their own government. It's a
>> playbook the Syrians are good at: The shelling of Homs began on Feb. 3,
>> 2012 -- exactly 30 years after the Hama massacre, in which Hafez al-Assad,
>> Bashar's father, killed up to 15,000 civilians over three weeks in a
>> similar program of wanton destruction.
>> What we haven't seen as clearly is the extent to which the Syrian regime
>> (thanks to its Russian advisors) now has the tools of electronic warfare to
>> crush this popular uprising -- and anything that happens to get in the way.
>> Syria is one of Russia's biggest clients for weapons, training, and
>> intelligence. In return for such largesse, it has offered the Russian Navy
>> use of Tartus, a new deep-water military port in the Mediterranean. Moscow
>> sold Damascus nearly $1 billion<> worth
>> of weapons in 2011, despite growing sanctions against the oppressive Assad
>> regime. With these high-tech weapons comes the less visible
>> Russian-supplied training on technologies, tactics, and strategies.
>> The sounds of rockets pulverizing civilians should have brought back
>> memories and warnings to Colvin. She would have recognized all the signs
>> from her previous reporting in Chechnya, where she and her escorts were
>> hunted relentlessly by Russian domestic security agents who sought to
>> arrest, silence, or kill any journalist attempting to report on the
>> slaughter of civilians.
>> My time in Grozny included being surrounded three times by the Russian
>> army, numerous direct bombardments, and frequent close calls. I paid
>> attention to the safety warnings of the Chechen rebel commanders who kept
>> me alive. These rebels were once part of the Soviet military and
>> intelligence apparatus and were fully schooled in Russia's dirty tricks.
>> They taught me much. Chief among them was not communicating electronically
>> while in country, not trusting "media guides," and never telling people
>> where I was going. If captured by Russian troops, they urged me -- for my
>> own safety -- to say that I had been kidnapped by Chechen forces.
>> Just as I exited Chechnya, I met Colvin, who was heading in. She wanted
>> to know as much as she could. I warned her of the duplicity and violent
>> intent of the Russian military and their Chechen proxies. Despite my
>> warnings, she bravely entered Chechnya and wrote riveting, award-winning
>> stories<> that
>> now sound almost identical to her coverage from Syria.
>> I was distressed to read of Colvin's death in Syria, and even more
>> distressed to think she might still be alive now if she had remembered some
>> basic warnings. Her first error was that she stayed inside the rebel "media
>> center" -- in reality, a four-story family home converted to this use as it
>> was one of the few places that had a generator.
>> The second was communication. The Syrian army had shut down the
>> cell-phone system and much of the power in Baba Amr -- and when journalists
>> sent up signals it made them a clear target. After CNN's Arwa Damon broadcast
>> live<> from
>> the "media center" for a week, the house was bombarded until the top floor
>> collapsed. Colvin may have been trapped, but she chose to make multiple
>> phone reports and even went live on CNN<> and
>> other media channels, clearly mentioning that she was staying in the bombed
>> building.
>> The third mistake was one of tone. She made her sympathies in the
>> besieged city clearly known as she emotionally described the horrors and
>> documented the crimes of the Syrian government.
>> Unsurprisingly, the next day at 9 a.m., a barrage of rockets was launched
>> at the "media center." She was killed -- along her cameraman, Remi Ochlik<>,
>> and at least 80 Syrian civilians across the city -- targeted with precision
>> rocket barrages, bombs, and the full violence of the Syrian army.
>> In Grozny, Russian forces decided that they would eliminate everything,
>> everybody, and every voice that stood up to the state -- including
>> journalists who tried to enter. Syria has clearly made the same
>> determination in Homs. This military action is intended to be a massacre, a
>> Stalinist-style lesson to those who dare defy the rulers of Syria.
>> The United Nations estimates<> that
>> more than 7,500 Syrians have so far been killed in the yearlong spasm of
>> violence there. Perhaps this ghastly toll would be even higher now if brave
>> reporters like Colvin had not entered. With the recent news that the rebels
>> have retreated from the bombardment of Baba Amr to safer territory, Assad's
>> forces, as well as their Russian advisors, are claiming victory. According
>> to official news reports from the Syrian Information Ministry, "the
>> foreign-backed mercenaries and armed terrorist groups" have fled, the
>> corpses of three Western journalists have been "discovered," and Homs is
>> now "peaceful."
>> Despite what Damascus claims, this fight is not yet over. And we need
>> more brave and bright journalists who will shine a light in places like
>> Syria, where a regime works diligently to plunge its people into darkness.
>> But let's not forget whose callous playbook they're using.
>> ****
>> Save big when you *subscribe* to FP.<>
>> _______________________________________________
>> liberationtech mailing list
>> liberationtech at
>> Should you need to change your subscription options, please go to:
>> If you would like to receive a daily digest, click "yes" (once you click
>> above) next to "would you like to receive list mail batched in a daily
>> digest?"
>> You will need the user name and password you receive from the list
>> moderator in monthly reminders.
>> Should you need immediate assistance, please contact the list moderator.
>> Please don't forget to follow us on!/Liberationtech
>> _______________________________________________
>> liberationtech mailing list
>> liberationtech at
>> Should you need to change your subscription options, please go to:
>> If you would like to receive a daily digest, click "yes" (once you click
>> above) next to "would you like to receive list mail batched in a daily
>> digest?"
>> You will need the user name and password you receive from the list
>> moderator in monthly reminders.
>> Should you need immediate assistance, please contact the list moderator.
>> Please don't forget to follow us on!/Liberationtech


Brian Conley

Director, Small World News

m: 646.285.2046

Skype: brianjoelconley

public key:<>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <>

More information about the liberationtech mailing list