Search Mailing List Archives
[liberationtech] Boundless Informant: the NSA's secret tool to track global surveillance data
jacob at appelbaum.net
Sun Jun 9 06:15:49 PDT 2013
> 2013/6/8 Jacob Appelbaum <jacob at appelbaum.net>
>> Oh man, Glenn Greenwald is my hero and a hero to us all.
> Do you still believe Glenn's reporting that NSA has "direct access to
> servers of firms including Google, Apple and Facebook"?
Yeah, I think it is clearly a FISA interface or API of some kind. Either
that or it is pwnage of the server. Probably one or the other in some cases.
> In my view, he
> misled the world intentionally (the few prism training slides published did
> not seem to claim this). Glenn is at best a wacky journalist without common
He just broke the story of the decade, good to know your views on him.
> His reporting on the Verizon case was good, but I think his credibility
> bankrupted after the PRISM one.
We disagree, obviously. You'll see soon enough and when you're eating
crow, I'm sure we'll have another discussion.
> Everyone on
>> this list who was looking for 'some evidence' about global surveillance
>> and previously ignored all other evidence, well, here you go!
>> "Revealed: The NSA's powerful tool for cataloguing data – including
>> figures on US collection"
>> This screenshot from the program is very web 2.0:
>> The NSA is spying on the US and on the rest of the planet. There is no
>> ability to deny this anymore. Anyone who denies it is a complete moron.
>> I don't understand why this "evidence" is significant in any way. NSA
> certainly has lots of information, and a web2.0'ish tool is nothing
> surprising. It's rather moot to state "anyone who denies it is a complete
> moron". It's like the highway patrol keeping my driving record.
Why does it matter if you are surprised?
Also, your analogy is tired and boring. This is nothing like a highway
> Again, I'm not rooting for NSA. I think its power need to be limited and it
> needs more transparency. But I hate using misinformation or hyperbole to
> achieve that goal. This hurts the credibility of all the pro-privacy groups
> in general.
I don't see any misinformation or hyperbole from Glenn. I see
contradicting claims between governments and corporations. I also see
that he wanted to ensure everyone understood what each side claimed.
Note the very carefully worded denials all around.
All the best,
More information about the liberationtech