Search Mailing List Archives


Limit search to: Subject & Body Subject Author
Sort by: Reverse Sort
Limit to: All This Week Last Week This Month Last Month
Select Date Range     through    

[liberationtech] Secret European deals to hand over private data to America

Parker Higgins parker at eff.org
Sat Jun 29 16:09:22 PDT 2013


It was an Observer article, which shares a website with the Guardian despite separate staff and editorial. It was also heavily dependent on Wayne Madsen as a source, and he is a crackpot.

Guardian removed the article when they discovered what happened. Check Glenn Greenwald's timeline on Twitter for many explanations of that series of events.

Parker

Jurre andmore <drwhax at gmail.com> wrote:
>Oddness all over the place, it seems the story has been pulled by the
>Guardian. Anyone who knows more?
>
>2013/6/29 Paul Bernal (LAW) <Paul.Bernal at uea.ac.uk>:
>> None of this should be surprising, should it? It's a reasonable
>assumption that all intelligence agencies share their data on a pretty
>regular basis - certainly with 'friendly' nations, and almost certainly
>with others, on a quid pro quo basis. It's always been that way.
>>
>> On 29 Jun 2013, at 21:42, "Jurre andmore" <drwhax at gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>>> There was a hearing last week in Dutch parliament about PRISM. There
>>> was another interesting point being discussed a rumor that the
>TAT-14
>>> cable in Katwijk was being eavesdropped. Not only is it
>eavesdropped,
>>> but data is shared with the US!
>>>
>>> Article below:
>>>
>>> Revealed: secret European deals to hand over private data to America
>>>
>>> Germany 'among countries offering intelligence' according to new
>>> claims by former US defence analyst
>>>
>>>
>>> At least six European Union countries in addition to Britain have
>been
>>> colluding with the US over the mass harvesting of personal
>>> communications data, according to a former contractor to America's
>>> National Security Agency, who said the public should not be "kept in
>>> the dark".
>>>
>>> Wayne Madsen, a former US navy lieutenant who first worked for
>theNSA
>>> in 1985 and over the next 12 years held several sensitive positions
>>> within the agency, names Denmark, the Netherlands, France, Germany,
>>> Spain and Italy as having secret deals with the US.
>>>
>>> Madsen said the countries had "formal second and third party status"
>>> under signal intelligence (Sigint) agreements that compels them to
>>> hand over data, including mobile phone and internet information to
>the
>>> NSA if requested.
>>>
>>> Under international intelligence agreements, confirmed by
>declassified
>>> documents, nations are categorised by the US according to their
>trust
>>> level. The US is first party while the UK, Canada, Australia and New
>>> Zealand enjoy second party relationships. Germany and France have
>>> third party relationships.
>>>
>>> In an interview published last night on the PrivacySurgeon.org blog,
>>> Madsen, who has been attacked for holding controversial views on
>>> espionage issues, said he had decided to speak out after becoming
>>> concerned about the "half story" told by EU politicians regarding
>the
>>> extent of the NSA's activities in Europe.
>>>
>>> He said that under the agreements, which were drawn up after the
>>> second world war, the "NSA gets the lion's share" of the Sigint
>>> "take". In return, the third parties to the NSA agreements received
>>> "highly sanitised intelligence".
>>>
>>> Madsen said he was alarmed at the "sanctimonious outcry" of
>political
>>> leaders who were "feigning shock" about the spying operations while
>>> staying silent about their own arrangements with the US, and was
>>> particularly concerned that senior German politicians had accused
>the
>>> UK of spying when their country had a similar third party deal with
>>> the NSA.
>>>
>>> Although the level of co-operation provided by other European
>>> countries to the NSA is not on the same scale as that provided by
>the
>>> UK, the allegations are potentially embarrassing.
>>>
>>> "I can't understand how Angela Merkel can keep a straight face,
>>> demanding assurances from Obama and the UK while Germany has entered
>>> into those exact relationships," Madsen said.
>>>
>>> The Liberal Democrat MEP Baroness Ludford, a senior member of the
>>> European parliament's civil liberties, justice and home affairs
>>> committee, said Madsen's allegations confirmed that the entire
>system
>>> for monitoring data interception was a mess, because the EU was
>unable
>>> to intervene in intelligence matters that remained the exclusive
>>> concern of national governments.
>>>
>>> "The intelligence agencies are exploiting these contradictions and
>no
>>> one is really holding them to account," Ludford said. "It's terribly
>>> undermining to liberal democracy."
>>>
>>> Madsen's disclosures have prompted calls for European governments to
>>> come clean on their arrangements with the NSA. "There needs to be
>>> transparency as to whether or not it is legal for the US or any
>other
>>> security service to interrogate private material," said John Cooper
>>> QC, a leading international human rights lawyer. "The problem here
>is
>>> that none of these arrangements has been debated in any democratic
>>> arena. I agree with William Hague that sometimes things have to be
>>> done in secret, but you don't break the law in secret."
>>>
>>> Madsen said all seven European countries and the US have access to
>the
>>> Tat 14 fibre-optic cable network running between Denmark and
>Germany,
>>> the Netherlands, France, the UK and the US, allowing them to
>intercept
>>> vast amounts of data, including phone calls, emails and records of
>>> users' access to websites.
>>>
>>> He said the public needed to be made aware of the full scale of the
>>> communication-sharing arrangements between European countries and
>the
>>> US, which pre-date the internet and became of strategic importance
>>> during the cold war.
>>>
>>> The covert relationship between the countries was first outlined in
>a
>>> 2001 report by the European parliament, but their explicit
>connection
>>> with the NSA was not publicised until Madsen decided to speak out
>last
>>> night.
>>>
>>> The European parliament's report followed revelations that the NSA
>was
>>> conducting a global intelligence-gathering operation, known as
>>> Echelon, which appears to have established the framework for
>European
>>> member states to collaborate with the US.
>>>
>>> "A lot of this information isn't secret, nor is it new," Madsen
>said.
>>> "It's just that governments have chosen to keep the public in the
>dark
>>> about it. The days when they could get away with a conspiracy of
>>> silence are over."
>>>
>>> This month another former NSA contractor, Edward Snowden, revealed
>to
>>> the Guardian previously undisclosed US programmes to monitor
>telephone
>>> and internet traffic. The NSA is alleged to have shared some of its
>>> data, gathered using a specialist tool called Prism, with Britain's
>>> GCHQ, although the British government denies any suggestion that it
>>> was obtained illegally. In return, GCHQ has allegedly provided huge
>>> amounts of data to the NSA.
>>>
>>> "The European parliament must intervene," said Simon Davies, who
>runs
>>> the Privacy Surgeon blog. "MEPs should put the interests of citizens
>>> above party politics and create meaningful reforms."
>>>
>>>
>http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/29/european-private-data-america?CMP=twt_fd
>>>
>>> --
>>> With kind regards,
>>>
>>> Jurre van Bergen
>>> --
>>> Too many emails? Unsubscribe, change to digest, or change password
>by emailing moderator at companys at stanford.edu or changing your
>settings at
>https://mailman.stanford.edu/mailman/listinfo/liberationtech
>> --
>> Too many emails? Unsubscribe, change to digest, or change password by
>emailing moderator at companys at stanford.edu or changing your settings
>at https://mailman.stanford.edu/mailman/listinfo/liberationtech
>
>
>
>-- 
>With kind regards,
>
>Jurre van Bergen
>--
>Too many emails? Unsubscribe, change to digest, or change password by
>emailing moderator at companys at stanford.edu or changing your settings
>at https://mailman.stanford.edu/mailman/listinfo/liberationtech

-- 
Brevity generally requires no excuse, but nonetheless I provide: this missive was composed on a mobile keyboard.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mailman.stanford.edu/pipermail/liberationtech/attachments/20130629/62bb97ea/attachment.html>


More information about the liberationtech mailing list