Search Mailing List Archives

Limit search to: Subject & Body Subject Author
Sort by: Reverse Sort
Limit to: All This Week Last Week This Month Last Month
Select Date Range     through    

[liberationtech] dark mail alliance

Sacha van Geffen sacha at
Fri Nov 1 08:44:28 PDT 2013

Lavabit, Silent Circle Form New Anti-Surveillance Dark Mail Alliance
by Dennis Fisher	  	October 30, 2013 , 3:18 pm

As the stunning revelations about the NSA’s collection methods and
capabilities continue to mount, two secure email providers that have
shut down their services in recent months have formed a new alliance to
develop and deploy a new secure email platform that will be resistant to
surveillance and back doors. The Dark Mail Alliance, formed Wednesday by
Silent Circle and Lavabit, aims to put together an open protocol and
architecture for private email.

Both Lavabit and Silent Circle made the decision this summer to pull the
plug on their respective secure email services, for different, but
related, reasons. Lavabit, a provider of encrypted private email
services, in August said that it would pull the plug on its service. At
first the company didn’t provide many details on why the decision had
been made, but it gradually became clear that Lavabit founder Ladar
Levison had decided to shut the service down rather than comply with a
government request for access to the master encryption key for the
service. Edward Snowden, the NSA whistle blower, was a Lavabit user, and
the FBI wanted access to his email, but was also asking for access to
other users’ accounts. Levison instead shut the service down.

Soon afterward, officials at Silent Circle came to the decision that
they needed to end their Silent Mail offering, as well, as they assumed
it also would be a prime target for government surveillance requests.

“We said we had to do something and do it now, and tell people why we
did. I had to think about it in terms of if I were [the government],
what would I be doing? I would be typing up the subpoenas to be
delivered at 7 a.m.,” Jon Callas, co-founder of Silent Circle, said at
the time of the shutdown in August.

Now, the two companies are pooling their resources in an effort to get a
new secure email platform off the ground. Truly secure and private email
has proven to be a challenge for more than a decade now, but officials
from the two companies say that the need is there.

“Together our mission is simple: To bring the world a unique end-to-end
encrypted protocol and architecture that is the ‘next-generation’ of
private and secure email. What we call ‘Email 3.0.’ is an urgent
replacement for today’s decades old email protocols (‘1.0’) and mail
that is encrypted but still relies on vulnerable protocols leaking
metadata (‘2.0’),” they said in a blog post announcing the alliance.

“Our goal is to open source the protocol and architecture and help
others implement this new technology to address the privacy concerns
over surveillance and back door threats of any kind.”

How the alliance will proceed and what the technology will look like
remain to be seen, but the interest in this kind of technology in the
security and privacy communities is quite high, especially given the
revelations of the last few months.


Greenhost - Sustainable Hosting
T: +31204890444
info at

A digital signature can be attached to this e-mail,
you need opengpg software to verify it. see:

Key fingerprint = 4F15 CE56 36AB A1C2 0D81  BE10 E12B B435 F2D5 2E48

More information about the liberationtech mailing list